Film versus Nachhaltigkeit?

Eine persönliche Stellungsnahme von Daniela Ingruber / Diagonale.

Erste Reaktion: „Natürlich machen wir mit!“

Als klar wurde, dass DIAGONALE GOES GREEN wesentlich mehr werden sollte, als ein bisschen Papier einzusparen, abends Computer und Licht auszuschalten und Fair Trade Café zu trinken, wurde die Euphorie leiser. Schließlich ging es auf die heiße Phase der Festivalvorbereitung zu, da hatte man wirklich andere Sorgen!

Zweite Reaktion: „Nachhaltigkeit? Das Festival des österreichischen Films als Green Event? Sollten wir uns nicht eher auf Filme konzentrieren?“
Warum denn nicht beides, lautete die Antwort.

Dritte Reaktion – diesmal nur zu mir selbst gesprochen: „Ich muss irgendwie die Texte, die rausgehen werden, an mich reißen. Immerhin habe ich früher in Umwelt-NGOs gearbeitet!“ Düster sah ich die Zukunft: Ein Marketinggag würde den nächsten jagen, alles fein grün angehaucht, eine Neubewertung dessen, was man sowieso längst macht, schon allein deswegen, weil es heute gar nicht mehr anders geht. Ich wollte das Schlimmste verhindern, bastelte tatsächlich am Text herum, schüttelte den Kopf über die vermeintliche Naivität – und tat mir gleichzeitig recht schwer, nicht doch ein wenig Freude zu empfinden.

Es sei ein Versuch, hieß es, während gleichzeitig mit viel Engagement alles in die Wege geleitet wurde, um gleich im ersten Jahr das Konzept möglichst durchgehend umsetzen zu können. Das Catering wurde auf Mehrweg umgestellt, der Papierverbrauch genau bemessen, auch was die Werbematerialien unserer Partner/innen betraf; die Rückführung von nicht verwendeten Ressourcen wurde in die Wege geleitet, Sponsoren und Partner/innen der Diagonale angehalten, keine Give-aways, die aus Plastik oder unter ungeklärten Arbeitsbedingungen hergestellt wurden, zur Verfügung zu stellen, sondern gemeinsam nachhaltige Produkte zu suchen.

„Gemeinsam“, das war bald eine der unausgesprochenen Regeln: Die Sponsoren wurden beraten, ressourcenschonende Marketingmaßnahmen überlegt und umgesetzt. Zur Nachahmung anzuregen war ein zweites Anliegen.

Zunächst ein wenig verwunderlich war die Offenheit jener, die mit der Diagonale zusammenarbeiten. Die meisten suchten gerne nach neuen Wegen. Bald war klar, dass es hier um mehr ging als um das Schönfärben. Der Zeitgeist? Vielleicht einfach das Wissen, dass wir es uns insgesamt nicht mehr leisten können, nicht umzudenken.

Tatsächlich veränderte sich etwas, auch intern: Zwar wird der Widerspruch, dass sich ein Filmfestival eigentlich ganz und gar dem Film widmen soll, dass es dazu aber auch zwingend Sponsoring, Förderungen und Kooperationen braucht, immer wieder durchschillern, doch heute fragt niemand mehr, ob DIAGONALE GOES GREEN vom Engagement um den österreichischen Film ablenken könnte. Die Diskussionen haben sich ins Inhaltliche verlagert. Als sie bei der sozialen Nachhaltigkeit ankommen, wandelt sich auch meine Skepsis. Nur zugeben würde ich das ungern, schließlich beginnt bald wieder die heiße Phase der Festivalvorbereitung.

Daniela Ingruber ist seit 2006 Mitarbeiterin der Diagonale – Festival des österreichischen Films. Als Associate Professor for Media, Conflict and Peace Studies lehrt sie an der United Nations University for Peace in Costa Rica, sowie an weiteren internationalen Universitäten, vorwiegend zu den Themen Medien(ethik) und Kriegsberichterstattung. Die ehemalige Chefredakteurin des planet° – Zeitung für politische Ökologie war zudem in mehreren Umwelt-NGOs tätig.

Shedding light on sustainability

Thomas Weber on how to create a more ecologic, in other words, better festival

Is there even such a thing as a sustainable festival? Isn’t the club scene by its very definition obliged to live in the moment, refusing to worry about tomorrow? Doesn’t it stand for a glamorous way of life defined by wastefulness, excess and hedonism?

The fundie says: Sound:frame was never designed to be sustainable. The very attempt to make a festival for audiovisual expressions sustainable seems absurd and strangely inconsist- ent. To save electricity one needs to simply turn off the lights. Let’s just leave it at that. Period.

The realist says: This attitude seems rather conservative. Of course it is possible for a festival for visual culture to be sustainable. In fact, it has to be! Dealing with this issue is far more than just a matter of eco-power or energy efficiency.

Being a realo, I was introduced to this topic in 2006. The initial idea, which set the ball rolling, came from the very top: during its EU presidency, Austria took the opportunity to organize the conference “Greening Events” at the Hofburg. Much has happened since then. Some festivals disappeared; others became considerably bigger, yet there’s still too much of everything. Even quite unsustainable rock festivals such as the Frequency Festival have a system of can deposit that functions smoothly within the course of the festival, which is a good enough reason to talk about introducing a nation-wide can deposit.

Some things never change, though: to turn an event “green” – to adjust it to or at least orientate it towards sustainable criteria is a fundamentally different approach than to create an event on sustainability that is pleased to represent an end in itself. Apart from environmental awareness, a politically pragmatic framework proves to be of great importance, as it is not necessarily set to create laws, but alternatives and incentive sys- tems. The system of “rentable” cups introduced in 2005, sets a good example and has recently been referred to as a best practice example, as the City of Hamburg launched its „Green Capital“ initiative in 2011. According to several studies, compostable one-way cups are not significantly different than one-way cups made out of plastic. Since 2005 event promoters are alternatively provided with returnable hard plastic cups introduced by the Viennese Municipal Depart- ment 48 responsible for environmental protection and waste management.

Each cup can be used up to 150 times and has helped to avoid waste at Vienna’s Donauin- selfest, the Life Ball and the sound:frame festival. The initially plain cups are now available in different and attractive designs. Now that ecologic sustainability has become a trend, it’s not always easy to tell the difference between genuine efforts and superficial “greenwashing”.

The fundie says: It’s scandalous. Greenwashing needs to be strictly forbidden; those responsible should be boycotted, brought to justice and punished.

The realist, however, feels conflicted: Is his ar- gument justified or is this halfhearted approach still better than nothing? Could it be considered a first step in the right direction? Obviously, only easily convinced individuals really buy into these superficial sustainability programs launched by major corporations. Although on the face of it, it’s particularly hard to find out what is really behind such initiatives. How to decide whether such an initiative is indeed a cheap form of greenwashing or an initial, cautious attempt of a dedicated supporter in hope of convincing skeptical colleagues to contribute to further efforts? That’s why interpretation attempts remain ambiguous.

Let’s bring this to-and-fro to an end: How to make a festival like sound:frame more sustain- able? Since this question requires a structural approach, the festival crew should not back away from seeking professional help, when looking for short, medium and long-term answers.

The Austrian Institute of Ecology or the Eco- BusinessPlan Vienna are excellent advisors as they offer necessary expertise as well as references. To successfully approach sustainability criteria, special needs of smaller, club-oriented festivals need to be met.

Small festivals have a natural advantage over major rock festivals in the middle of nowhere, as their stages have been operated by diesel generator sets up until now, while the majority of visitors arrive by car and their infrastructure needs to be built from scratch (wastewater, gar- bage, energy, traffic, IT equipment etc). Subsequently, in terms of sustainability festivals like sound:frame have a clear head start over rural rock spectacles, as they are free to make use of existing infrastructures in Vienna, which are already in accordance with desired standards concerning energy, waste management and public transportation. Now, how to gradually start raising environmental awareness of crew-members, visitors, sponsors and promoters to eventually achieve concrete and desired results? This is only one of many important questions, most of which have not yet been answered.

Traffic

Could visitors arriving on foot, by bike or by public transport receive tickets at a discount? How to motivate international artists to travel by train instead by plane?

Energy

How to save energy? Key word: efficiency. Is it possible for temporary tenants of a location to temporarily switch from current energy suppliers to strictly green electricity? Could attempts like that convince the location to change over to environmentally-friendly suppliers? Especially during transitional periods: It’s no coincidence that a ban on mushroom heaters has repeatedly been at the center of debate.

Waste management

Not every location collects its waste separately: Now, how to improve the general waste man- agement of a location, particularly within the scope of a festival? Considering that reusable cups are already in use, is it possible to completely avoid cans or to introduce a temporary can deposit? This would enable visitors to contribute to the recycling process.

Gastronomy and catering

Only few locations are open to negotiations regarding their gastronomy. Nevertheless, there is still plenty of room for improvement: although one-way bottles are quite popular, from an ecological perspective they contribute towards a worst-case scenario. How to promote draft beer (preferably organic) in reusable cups? Where and how to set up water dispensers to provide free water for visitors? Just like major festivals, smaller events benefit from the proven principle of providing only sandwiches to help reduce waste, such as paper plates or disposable cutlery. Generally, it’s important to set a good example when it comes to catering for crewmembers and artists by favoring organic and seasonal food as well as regional and fairtrade products – preferably all at once.

Accommodation

Where do artists and other participants stay during the course of a festival? When accommodating artists it’s important to consider alternatives, such as the Boutique Hotel Stadthalle (zero energy-hotel) that offers a green bonus, a discount of 10 %, for those traveling by train or by bicycle. Can locations be easily reached by public transport or bicycle?

Sponsoring

Sustainability as a core theme should not only inspire crewmembers or visitors, but also promoters and sponsors, who likewise profit from an event’s sustainable image. Within this context, it’s crucial to by no means support greenwashing. Further, it’s important for a genuinely sustainable festival to not collaborate with a sponsor whose products are not in line with sustainability criteria. Yet, ecologically fundamentalist attitudes are uncalled-for as every situation requires a very own approach. Can a festival become a pioneer through setting a good example? Now, that sustainability has become a trend, it is by no means morally reprehensible to use it as a competitive advantage – as long as interests and efforts seem genuinely honest. A good image will increasingly attract those involved: the audience, the promoters and the sponsors.

Social factors

How to make a festival that thrives on its sub-cultural and passionate self-image switch to socially sustainable structures? To which extent is self-exploitation regarded as a form of investment? Leaving some things the way they are could also be considered sustainable.

How to harmoniously organize working conditions for everybody involved? When is the principle of flexibility used as a false pretense, worsening already precarious conditions? How to deal with actual forms of illegal employment or illegal money that quite a few DJs, VJs and caterers depend on?

Communication

Does every program item require flyers and posters? By now, flyers, posters and other printed forms are available at a reasonable price using ecologically certified paper. FSC paper has now become a minimum requirement for sustainable festivals and an ecologically friendly online print ship has recently opened up, not far from Vienna: www.fairprint-shop.at. Which media partners are suitable for collaboration?

Program contents

Is it possible to incorporate sustainability as a concept into individual program parts and core themes of the festival? Could icons of the club scene support and promote collective efforts? How to firmly integrate sustainability into the process and into different parts of the festival? e. g.: a cooperation with the open source campaign www.eingutertag.org

Questions upon questions – all of which have yet to be answered. But let’s be honest: the only thing sustainability really needs is wholehearted support.

Thomas Weber / monopol.at, editor of Biorama – a magazine for sustainable living – and The Gap

(Initially written for sound:frame festival)

a green(er) festival

sound:frame festival 2012 – „substructions“

“Green Light – go!” on Vimeo

sound:frame, das Festival for audiovisual expressions Wien, veranstaltet neben einer Ausstellung in jedem Jahr ein umfassendes Live Performance und Diskursprogramm in Wien. In den ersten fünf Jahren wurden vordergründig kunst- und kulturtheoretische Themen behandelt. Im sechsten Festivaljahr 2012 setzte sich sound:frame unter dem Titel „substructions“ erstmals mit den Rahmenbedingungen audiovisueller Kunst(produktion) und Festivalorganisation auseinander.

Einer der drei diskutierten Schwerpunkte befasste sich mit dem Thema sustainability und hatte das Erstellen eines kurz-, mittel- und langfristigen Maßnahmenkataloges zum Ziel.

Schon im Vorfeld des Festivals fand in Kooperation mit BIORAMA der Roundtable „Green light – go!“ statt. Gemeinsam mit Expertinnnen und Experten aus den Bereichen Ökologie, Soziologie und Wirtschaft wurde dabei über aktuelle Tendenzen einer effizienteren Ressourcennutzung diskutiert: Welche leistbaren Schritte können multimediale Festivals gehen, um in ökonomischer wie ökologischer Hinsicht nachhaltiger zu werden? Welche Entwicklungen können einzelne Institutionen oder Künstler/innen vorantreiben? Welche Problematiken birgt der Wunsch, zum “Green Event” zu werden? Wie können die Visionen realistisch in die Tat umgesetzt werden?

In einer Diskussionsrunde während des sound:frame Festivals sprachen wir unter anderem mit Artemis Vakianis vom steirischen herbst. Auch Daniel Erlacher, einer der Leiter des Elevate Festivals in Graz, beteiligte sich rege an der Diskussion.

Kleine Schritte sind ein Beginn. Viele gemeinsame kleine Schritte führen schon weiter. Daher freue ich mich über die Zusammenarbeit und den Austausch mit Festivals wie dem steirischen herbst!

Eva Fischer, Initiatorin und Leiterin des sound:frame Festivals/ Wien

www.soundframe.at